SIP or FD? The Truth Your Banker Won’t Tell You

A few weeks ago, a gentleman named Sunil walked into my office looking restless. He had just come from his bank, where the relationship manager had been pitching him yet another Fixed Deposit (FD). 

Arif bhai, he said, the banker told me FD is safe and guaranteed. But my friend keeps telling me SIP is the smarter choice. Who should I believe?

This is one of the most common questions I get as a financial consultant. Instead of giving Sunil a boring technical answer, I told him a story.

---

SIP vs FD: Why Bankers Always Push Fixed Deposits

Picture this. You walk into your bank. The walls are covered with posters about Assured Returns and Safe Investment Options. The banker smiles, offers tea, and quickly brings out the FD form.

Why? Because for the banker, FD is simple. It keeps money locked in the bank, it feels safe for the customer, and the banker earns recognition for deposits.

But here’s the catch FDs give safety, not growth.

---

FD Interest Rates vs Inflation

FD is like keeping your money in a safe box. It won’t disappear, and you know exactly how much you’ll get back.

But if your FD pays 6% and inflation is also 6%, your real growth is zero. Add taxes on FD interest, and you might actually lose purchasing power.

This is the side of FDs your banker never highlights.

---

What is SIP in Mutual Funds?

Now let’s talk about SIP (Systematic Investment Plan).

SIP is not a product it’s a disciplined way of investing in mutual funds. You invest a fixed amount every month, and over time, compounding works in your favor.

Yes, markets fluctuate. But history shows that over 10–20 years, equity mutual funds have comfortably beaten inflation and built real wealth.

Think of SIP as planting a tree. Some seasons are tough, but given time, it grows into something strong enough to support your family.

---

SIP vs FD Returns: A Real-Life Example

I gave Sunil a simple calculation:

₹10,000 per month in FD at 6% for 15 years about ₹29 lakhs after tax.

₹10,000 per month in SIP averaging 12% for 15 years around ₹50 lakhs.

When Sunil saw the numbers, his eyes widened.

The banker never showed me this comparison, he said.

And that’s the truth they won’t.

---

Why Bankers Don’t Talk About SIPs

Bankers rarely highlight SIPs because mutual funds are not their main business. They’d rather sell you FDs or insurance-linked products that earn them higher commissions.

Does this mean FDs are useless? Not at all. For short-term parking (6–12 months) or for people who cannot take any risk, FDs are fine. But for long-term wealth creation in India, SIP beats FD hands down.

---

SIP vs FD: Which is Better for Indians?

Here’s how I explained it to Sunil:

FDs protect your capital but don’t grow it.

SIPs grow your capital and help you beat inflation.

FDs are short-term tools, SIPs are long-term wealth creators.

Sunil leaned back and smiled. So I should start a SIP right away?

I replied, Yes and it’s a habit you’ll thank yourself for 15 years from now.

---

Final Word: The Truth Your Banker Won’t Tell You

If you’re reading this, remember:

• Your banker is not your financial advisor.
• Bankers sell what benefits the bank, not what builds your wealth.
• SIP in mutual funds may not be guaranteed, but over the long run, it’s your best bet to create financial freedom.

So the next time someone tells you about the guaranteed safety of FD, ask yourself:

Guaranteed for whom the bank, or your future?

---

FAQs on SIP vs FD

1. Is SIP riskier than FD?

Yes, SIPs are market-linked, so their value goes up and down in the short term. FDs are safe and guaranteed. But over the long run, SIPs have historically given higher returns and beaten inflation, while FDs often fail to do so.

2. Which is better for retirement: SIP or FD?

For retirement planning, SIP is far better because it grows your money over decades. FD can be used for short-term needs or as part of your retirement income once you stop working, but not as your main wealth creator.

3. Can I invest in both SIP and FD?

Absolutely. Use FDs for emergency funds, short-term goals, or guaranteed safety. Use SIPs for long-term wealth creation and financial freedom. The right balance depends on your goals and risk comfort.

4. Why do bankers recommend FD more than SIP?

Because FDs are the bank’s own product. It keeps your money with them and helps them meet their targets. SIPs are mutual fund investments and don’t give the same benefit to the banker.

5. How much should I start with in SIP?

Even ₹500 a month is enough to begin. The key is consistency, not the starting amount. Over time, you can increase it as your income grows.

---

Want to clear your doubts about SIPs, FDs, or any other investment?
I offer a free one-on-one consultation no sales pitch, no pressure. Just honest, practical advice from my 20+ years of experience in personal finance.

Connect with me directly on WhatsApp
or
Click here to book your free consultation 

Let’s make your money work smarter, not harder.

---